| 2008-09 |
| Men's Basketball - NABC Coaches Poll (Jan. 6, 2009) |
| #2 Bellarmine |
| #12 Southern Indiana |
| #18 Northern Kentucky |
| |
| Women's Basketball - USA Today/ESPN/WBCA Top 25 Coaches' Poll (Jan. 6, 2009) |
| #1 Northern Kentucky |
| #19 Indianapolis |
| |
| Volleyball - AVCA National Poll (Dec. 8, 2008 Final) |
| |
| Men's Soccer - NSCAA/adidas National Poll (Dec. 9, 2008 Final) |
| #4 Northern Kentucky |
| #11 Lewis |
| #15 Rockhurst |
| |
| Women's Soccer - NSCAA/adidas National Poll (Dec. 9, 2008 Final) |
| #6 UW-Parkside |
| #23 Northern Kentucky |
| |
| Men's Cross Country - USTFCCCA Top 25 Poll (Nov. 12, 2008 Final) |
| #13 Southern Indiana |
| |
| Women's Cross Country - USTFCCCA Top 25 Poll (Nov. 12, 2008 Final) |
| |
| Women's Golf - Golf World/NGCA Coaches Poll (Sept. 25, 2008) |
| #11 Indianapolis |
| #21 Drury |
| |
| Men's Golf - Golf World/Nike Golf Coaches Poll (Preseason) |
| #22 Indianapolis |
| |
| 2007-08 |
| Volleyball - AVCA National Poll (Dec. 3 - Final Poll) |
| #11 Lewis |
| #14 SIU Edwardsville |
| #17 Indianapolis |
| |
| Men's Soccer - NSCAA/adidas National Poll (Oct. 30 - Final Reg. Season) |
| #1 Northern Kentucky |
| #15 Lewis |
| #20 SIU Edwardsville |
| |
| Women's Soccer - NSCAA/adidas National Poll (Oct. 30 - Final Reg. Season) |
| #15 SIU Edwardsville |
| #22 Quincy |
| |
| Men's Cross Country - USTFCCCA Top 25 Poll (Oct. 31 - Final Poll) |
| #7 Southern Indiana |
| #17 Missouri-Rolla |
| #24 Northern Kentucky |
| |
| Women's Cross Country - USTFCCCA Top 25 Poll (Oct. 31 - Final Poll) |
| #8 UW-Parkside |
| #18 Southern Indiana |
| |
| Men's Basketball - NABC Coaches Poll (Final Poll) |
| #11 Drury |
| |
| Women's Basketball - USA Today/ESPN/WBCA Top 25 Coaches' Poll (Final Poll) |
| #1 Northern Kentucky |
| #11 Drury |
| |
| Men's Track & Field - USTFCCCA Complete Poll (Final) |
| #12 SIU Edwardsville |
| #33 Missouri S&T |
| |
| Women's Track & Field - USTFCCCA Complete Poll (Final) |
| #5 SIU Edwardsville |
| #29 UW-Parkside |
| #37 Bellarmine |
| #37 Indianapolis |
| #57 Saint Joseph's |
| |
| Men's Tennis - Fila Complete Poll (Final) |
| #4 Drury |
| |
| Women's Tennis - Fila Complete Poll (Final) |
| #18 Drury |
| |
| Baseball - Collegiate Baseball Newspaper Division II Poll (Final Poll) |
| #22 Saint Joseph's |
| |
| Softball - National Fastpitch Coaches Association Top 25 (Final Poll) |
| #11SIU Edwardsville |
| 2006-07 |
| Baseball - Collegiate Baseball Magazine Complete Poll (Final) |
| #4 Southern Indiana (43-23) |
| #T30 Southern Illinois University Edwardsville (37-17) |
| |
|
Men's Basketball - NABC Complete Poll (Final)
|
| #10 Southern Indiana (29-6) |
| |
| Women's Basketball - USA Today/ESPN/WBCA Complete Poll (Final) |
| #12 Lewis (28-4) |
| #14 Drury (25-9) |
| |
| Men's Soccer - NSCAA/adidas Complete Poll (Final) |
| #7 Northern Kentucky (16-3-3) |
| #8 Southern Illinois University Edwardsville (15-4-3) |
| |
| Women's Soccer - NSCAA/adidas Complete Poll (Final) |
| #18 Indianapolis (17-5-1) |
| #25 Quincy (16-5-0) |
| |
| Men's Tennis - Fila Complete Poll (Final) |
| #6 Drury (22-3) |
| |
| Women's Tennis - Fila Complete Poll (Final) |
| #29 Drury (19-5) |
| #38 Indianapolis (12-13) |
| |
| Men's Track & Field - USTFCCCA Complete Poll (Final) |
| #18 Southern Indiana |
| #25 Southern Illinois University Edwardsville |
| |
| Women's Track & Field - USTFCCCA Complete Poll (Final) |
| #10 Southern Illinois University Edwardsville |
| #13 UW-Parkside |
| #24 Southern Indiana |
| |
| Women's Golf - Golf World/NGCA Poll (Final) |
| #4 Drury |
| #18 Indianapolis |
| #21 Northern Kentucky |
| |
| Softball - NFCA Complete Poll (Final) |
| #1 Southern Illinois University Edwardsville (48-9) |
| |
| Volleyball - CSTV/AVCA Complete Poll (Final) |
| #14 Southern Illinois University Edwardsville (29-6) |